How to Perform an On-Page SEO Competitor Analysis: A Step-by-Step Guide

Picture this: You have just finished creating a visually stunning, engaging, and informative webpage that you’re incredibly proud of. But despite the hard work, you’re not getting the traffic or ranking results you expected. What could be going wrong? Well, it may be time for an on-page SEO competitor analysis.

Just like David vs. Goliath, taking on bigger competitors can feel daunting, but fear not! In this step-by-step guide to performing an On-Page SEO Competitor Analysis, we’ll show you how to successfully challenge your rivals by uncovering their strengths, weaknesses and ultimately turning the tables in your favor. Keep reading and let’s dive into this intriguing world of search engine optimization together!

Performing an On-Page SEO competitor analysis involves researching your competitors to gather insights about their on-page SEO strategies, strengths, and weaknesses. This information can help improve your own on-page SEO and ultimately beat your competitors. At On-Page AI, we provide tools that automate this process, including our Competitor Analysis tool which allows you to compare your page against your top competitors, analyze their content, uncover missing keywords or phrases so you can outrank them.

Understanding On-Page SEO Competitor Analysis

In the world of digital marketing, understanding your competitors is key to creating and implementing an effective SEO strategy. A big part of SEO competitor analysis is analyzing on-page factors that contribute to search engine rankings. By understanding what your competitors are doing well and where they fall short, you can identify areas for improvement and optimize your website accordingly.

On-page SEO competitor analysis involves evaluating various elements of your competitors’ web pages in order to gain insights into their strategies. These elements include keyword usage, page titles, meta descriptions, header tags, page speed, and more. By analyzing these factors, you can get a better sense of how your competitors structure their websites and what keywords they are targeting.

Without an understanding of your competitors’ on-page factors, you may struggle to increase the visibility of your website in search engines. This is because there is likely a wide range of competing websites in your industry that are already optimized for popular keywords. In order to stand out from the crowd and capture organic traffic from search engines like Google, it’s important to understand what works best for your competition.

To illustrate this point, let’s imagine that you own a small bakery in New York City. You’re looking to improve your online visibility so that customers searching for bakeries in NYC will find your website before your competitors’. After conducting an on-page SEO competitor analysis, you realize that most competing bakeries have strong content related to local keywords such as “NYC bakeries” or “best bakeries near me”. Armed with this information, you could then create content tailored specifically to these keywords in order to increase your chances of ranking higher within those search results.

The first step in conducting an effective on-page SEO competitor analysis is identifying who your competitors are. Once you have a clear sense of which websites are ranking well in search results within your industry, you can then start to evaluate the on-page factors that contribute to their success.

  • In the world of digital marketing, an effective SEO strategy requires a deep understanding of your competitors’ on-page factors that contribute to search engine rankings. By analyzing various elements such as keyword usage, page titles, meta descriptions, header tags, and page speed, you can gain insights into your competitors’ strategies and identify areas for improvement on your own website. Conducting an on-page competitor analysis is crucial to standing out from the crowd and capturing organic traffic from search engines like Google. The first step is identifying who your competitors are and evaluating their on-page factors that contribute to their success.

Step 1: Identify Your SEO Competitors

The first step in conducting an on-page SEO competitor analysis is identifying which sites you are competing with for search engine rankings. This can be done by entering relevant keywords into a search engine and analyzing the sites that appear in the top results. You may also want to use specialized tools such as SEMrush or Ahrefs to gain insights into the backlink profiles of your competitors and identify new competitors that you were not previously aware of.

For example, let’s say that you run an e-commerce site selling yoga mats. To identify your SEO competitors, you might start by searching for terms like “yoga mats”, “best yoga mats”, or “yoga mat reviews” in Google. By analyzing the websites that show up in the top results, you can get a sense of which other online retailers are your biggest competitors.

Once you’ve identified your competitors, it’s important to take note of various on-page factors in order to gain insights into their SEO strategy. This includes assessing their keyword usage, meta tags, headers, and more.

To continue with our yoga mat example, imagine that one of your main competitors is a well-known athletic apparel brand. After analyzing their website, you notice that they have optimized their product pages for terms like “yoga mats”, but also for broader terms like “workout gear”. This tells you that they are using a more generalized approach to target traffic beyond just people looking for yoga mats alone.

However, it’s important to remember that not all sites ranking highly for your chosen keywords will necessarily be true competitors- some may simply be getting lucky or targeting different audiences altogether. One way to differentiate between true competitors and those who are succeeding despite not being direct competition is to evaluate the backlink profiles of the various sites. Those with many high-quality backlinks from industry-relevant websites are more likely to be serious competitors, as these links are an important factor in determining search rankings.

Once you have a clear sense of which websites are your biggest competitors, it’s time to start evaluating their on-page factors to gain insights into their SEO strategy. In the next section, we will discuss some key factors to consider when conducting this analysis.

Step 2: Assess Competitors’ On-Page SEO Factors

Analyzing a competitor’s on-page SEO factors can provide valuable insights into their optimization efforts, helping you identify areas where you may be lacking. In this step, we’ll take a closer look at the three primary components of on-page SEO factors and how to effectively assess them: crawling and performance, keyword optimization, and website visibility.

Let’s say you’re a small business owner who runs an online clothing store. One of your primary competitors is a larger fashion retailer with a similar target audience. By assessing their on-page SEO factors, you may discover that while they have strong keyword optimization, their website has slow loading times, resulting in poor performance. This information can help you prioritize page speed optimizations over further keyword research.

The first component of on-page SEO factors to consider is crawling and performance. Search engines prioritize websites that load quickly and are easily crawled by search bots. Additionally, user experience is critical when it comes to website loading times – according to Google’s data “53% of mobile users abandon sites that take longer than three seconds to load”. Some tips on how to evaluate your competitor’s on-page crawling and performance include:

– Use website speed testing tools like Pingdom or GTMetrix to evaluate loading times and uncover potential bottlenecks or areas for improvement.

– Analyze your competitor’s codebase using Google’s PageSpeed Insights tool or Chrome’s DevTools console to see whether there may be coding issues affecting site performance.

– Identify common issues such as broken internal links or 404 errors that affect page crawlability.

Of course not all speed evaluation metric are equally important for your particular business or market segment. Although site loading times are important, many marketers focus too much effort on the so-called “perfect score” in Google’s PageSpeed Insights test, when in reality this metric itself is not always reasonable – almost no website scores 100.

In a way, this is like a marathon runner trying to cut down their running time by just losing some weight. While it’s true that carrying less weight may help them run faster, it cannot be the only strategy to improve their performance as other factors such as technique or equipment also play critical roles.

The second component of on-page SEO factors to evaluate is keyword optimization – essentially how well your competition’s web pages are optimized for specific search queries. The objective here is to understand which keywords they focus on and how effective their keyword utilization strategies are. Here are some tips on how you can effectively evaluate competitors’ keyword optimization efforts:

  • According to research by Backlinko, the average word count of a top-ranking content on Google is 1,447 words.
  • Data from HubSpot revealed that pages with longer meta descriptions (between 60-90 characters) have higher click-through rates than those with shorter ones.
  • A study by Moz found that pages ranking in the top 10 search results on Google have an average domain authority of around 50.

Analyzing Crawling and Performance

When assessing crawling and performance, there are two vital aspects to consider: the site structure and URL structure. The former encompasses the way your competitor has arranged their web pages through organization and interlinking; while the latter refers to the URL hierarchy system they use throughout the site.

Let’s say you’re a small retailer who sells kitchen supplies online, and you’ve identified one of your leading competitors is an e-commerce store selling similar items. By evaluating their site structure and URL hierarchy, you may notice where they organize products by functionality rather than brand name – allowing customers to filter based on cooking type or item type rather than merely navigating through an endless series of pages.

A well-thought-out site architecture provides multiple benefits that affect overall site health, including better crawlability, stronger category organization, clear information about individual page importance, better user experience, etc. Some tips on how to evaluate site structure include:

– Use SEO tools such as SEMrush or Ahrefs for a detailed insight into your competitor’s website linking structure. This shows you which pages are most important to your competitor’s site and the depth of their content hierarchies.

– Analyze their sitemap.xml file – this lets us see all the pages a competitor believes should be crawled by search engines. This will give you a better idea of their priorities, as they likely have only submitted their most important pages for crawling via the XML sitemap.

– Evaluate your competitors’ URL structure and formatting. Some aspects to consider include whether they use static or dynamic URLs and how they incorporate target keywords in them.

With respect to URL format, there’s no “one-size-fits-all” best practice that we can apply to all web pages. Tidier URL structures might look more appealing but in some cases it can result in parameters that lead to dynamic generated content being left out of the indexing process – impacting negatively on performance.

It’s very similar to an address system in a big city – while you want a simple and neat system, sometimes it is not achievable and even counterproductive. Instead, depending on the area density and characteristics, the regulations vary, leading to unique address systems in different neighborhoods.

Overall, analyzing competitors’ on-page SEO factors helps identify areas where we need improvement or those that we have yet not explored. The insights from such an analysis can provide valuable data-driven information for creating action items and formulating achievable goals toward winning over our competition.

Evaluating Keyword Optimization

When it comes to On-Page SEO Competitor Analysis, evaluating keyword optimization is crucial. Keywords play a significant role in improving search rankings and driving targeted traffic to your website. In this section, we will look at some steps that can be taken to analyze your competitors’ keyword optimization strategies.

Start by examining their website content. Look for specific keywords or phrases they are targeting and compare them with your own target keywords. Analyze the frequency of these keywords on their web pages and see how well they are targeted in titles, subtitles, and meta descriptions.

It’s essential to ensure that your competitor’s keyword strategy aligns with their overall business goals and objectives. For example, if they sell products rather than services, you would expect product-specific keywords to feature more prominently on their website.

Keep in mind that optimizing for high-volume keywords might not always be the best approach. While these keywords may generate a lot of traffic, if they are not relevant to your business or audience, the traffic may not convert into leads or sales.

Check whether your competitors are employing long-tail keywords as part of their strategy. Long-tail keywords generally have lower search volume but have more specific intent and higher conversion rates. You should also identify any gaps in your competitor’s keyword strategy where they are missing out on valuable opportunities.

Think about it like an onion. Layer by layer seeing exactly what’s happening with individual websites gives you a complete understanding of your current situation within the market.

Once you have evaluated your competitor’s keyword optimization strategy, move on to assessing their website visibility to gain further insights into their SEO performance.

Assessing Website Visibility

Assessing the website visibility of your competitors involves a thorough examination of various factors beyond just keyword optimization. These factors affect the ability of your competitors to rank highly in search results. In this section, we will look at some steps you can take to assess competitor website visibility.

Start by checking domain authority (DA). Domain Authority measures the overall quality and credibility of websites on a scale of 1-100. Websites with high DA are more likely to rank higher in search results.

An increase in DA is often linked to aspects such as backlinks from other trusted sites, a high-quality and relevant content strategy, and user experience signal. Therefore, analyzing competitors’ DA is an excellent way to identify areas where they may be outperforming your site.

It’s important to note that DA is just one factor among many others that influence website visibility. Google’s algorithm takes into account numerous other factors such as user experience and content quality before ranking a website.

Another critical factor in assessing website visibility is analyzing page speed. Pages that load quickly tend to have a better user experience, leading to higher conversion rates and lower bounce rates. Look for tools like Google PageSpeed Insights to evaluate your competitor’s current page speed and see how it compares with your site.

Additionally, think of it as indirect feedback provided by users clicking on SERP pages. It’s a comparison between what information people want displayed vs what information competitors provide for that niche.

By using these tips to assess your competitor’s website visibility, you gain a comprehensive understanding of their SEO performance. This analysis identifies strengths and weaknesses not only in their strategies but yours too. Using this analysis, you can improve various aspects of your On-Page SEO Optimizations and boost web rankings significantly.

Utilizing Your Analysis Results for Improvement

Now that you have identified your competitors and assessed their On-Page SEO factors, it’s time to put your analysis results into action. The insights you have gained should help you improve your own website’s SEO and ultimately beat your competitors.

One way to utilize your analysis results is to improve your website’s content. Use the information you gathered on your competitors’ content strategies to identify areas where you can add value with targeted keywords and engaging topics. This will not only help improve the relevance of your website, but also attract more visitors who are searching for those specific words.

Another way to put your analysis results into action is by enhancing your meta descriptions, titles, and headers. Analyze what tags and titles are working best for your competitors and adapt them to your own site. Remember, these elements are a critical part of On-Page SEO as they tell both users and search engines what each page is about.

While it’s important to focus on improving On-Page elements, don’t neglect off-page factors such as backlinks. Link building should be a critical part of any SEO strategy as it can increase the authority of your website and drive more traffic. However, link building requires some finesse and should be done in a natural way. Be sure to analyze how your competitors are building their links and adopt similar tactics.

Think of improving your website’s On-Page SEO like tending a garden. Regular watering (creating fresh content) and pruning (removing outdated elements) will help it grow strong. Analyzing On-Page factors help you identify exactly which areas need attention so that everything flourishes.

Overall, conducting an On-Page SEO competitor analysis can be incredibly helpful in improving the performance of your website.‘s offerings, such as the On-Page Scan and the Stealth Writer, can help with that by providing data-driven recommendations to improve your website’s ranking. With the insights you gain from analyzing your competitors, you’ll have a better understanding of what works and what doesn’t in your market, ultimately helping you outrank them.

Responses to Common Questions

What are the key components of a successful On-Page SEO competitor analysis?

The key components of a successful on-page SEO competitor analysis are:

1. Keyword research: Identify the keywords that your competitors are ranking for and target those keywords in your content.

2. Content analysis: Analyze the content of your competitor’s website to understand their strategy. Look for any gaps in their content that you can fill with unique and relevant content.

3. On-page optimization: Analyze your competitor’s on-page optimization tactics, such as meta tags, title tags, header tags, and image optimization. Emulate what works and improve upon it.

4. User experience: Analyze the user experience of your competitor’s website, including page speed, mobile friendliness, and navigation. Ensure that your website offers a better user experience than your competitors.

5. Backlink analysis: Analyze your competitor’s backlink profile to determine where they are getting their links from. Use this information to develop a link building strategy that will give you an edge over your competition.

According to a study conducted by Hubspot, businesses that perform regular competitor analysis are 2x more likely to be profitable than those that don’t. By analyzing your competitors’ on-page SEO tactics and implementing improvements in your own strategy, you can achieve higher rankings and drive more traffic to your website.

What tools and resources are necessary for performing an effective On-Page SEO competitor analysis?

To perform an effective on-page SEO competitor analysis, you’ll need several tools and resources at your disposal. Here are a few essential ones:

1. Keyword research tool: Identifying the keywords your competitors use on their websites is crucial for optimizing your own website’s content. Tools like Google Keyword Planner and SEMrush can help you find keywords that are relevant to your industry.

2. On-page optimization tool: Analyzing your competitors’ on-page optimization efforts can help you identify areas where you can improve. Tools like Moz and Ahrefs offer on-page optimization analysis features to help you determine whether your website pages are optimized for search engines or not.

3. Content analysis tool: Your content plays a vital role in improving your SEO ranking, so it’s important to have a clear understanding of how your competitors target their audience with high-quality blog posts, articles, or social media content. Tools such as Buzzsumo allows you to see what type of contents related to your keywords performs well in social media platforms or other websites.

4. Performance analytics tool: Measuring your website performance metrics is essential for understanding how your site compares to your competitors in terms of traffic, engagement rate, conversions, user experience, and search visibility. Google Analytics and Google Search Console remain two must-have free options for measuring site performance.

By using these tools and resources together harmoniously, you can easily create actionable insights that will help you outperform the competition in the search engines!

How can I determine which keywords my competitors are ranking for and target them on my own website?

One of the most effective ways to determine which keywords your competitors are ranking for and target them on your own website is by performing keyword research using specialized tools like SEMrush, Ahrefs, or Moz. These tools allow you to analyze your competitors’ keywords and identify their strengths and weaknesses in terms of SEO.

Once you have identified the keywords your competitors are targeting, you should prioritize those that are highly relevant to your business, have high search volume, and low competition. To do this, use keyword difficulty metrics provided by the aforementioned tools.

To further optimize your on-page content for these targeted keywords, make sure to include them strategically in your page titles, headers, meta descriptions, and body text. However, avoid overusing keywords as it can result in a penalty from search engines.

According to a study by Hubspot, companies that blog regularly receive 97% more inbound links and 434% more indexed pages than those that don’t. This means that consistent blogging with strategically integrated targeted keywords can significantly increase your website’s visibility in search engine results pages (SERPs) and drive more traffic to your site.

In summary, conducting a thorough competitor analysis using specialized tools can help you uncover valuable insights about the keywords your competitors are targeting. By prioritizing relevant and high-impact keywords for your business and integrating them into your on-page content strategically, you can improve your website’s visibility in SERPs and drive more traffic to your site.

What are some common mistakes to avoid when conducting an On-Page SEO competitor analysis?

When conducting an on-page SEO competitor analysis, there are some common mistakes to avoid if you want to get accurate insights and achieve favorable results. Here are some of the most important mistakes to steer clear of:

1. Focusing only on one competitor: It’s tempting to concentrate solely on your main competitor when analyzing their on-page SEO. However, this approach can backfire because your primary competitor may not have a strategy that is effective. Instead, look at several competitors and compare their strategies.

2. Comparing apples to oranges: When it comes to on-page SEO, it’s crucial to compare similar pages with similar content. If you choose two completely different websites or pages, the result will not be accurate.

3. Not using the right tools: There are several SEO tools out there that can aid in competitor analysis. Many marketers make the mistake of using free versions of these tools instead of investing in premium ones that provide deeper insights.

4. Ignoring mobile optimization: Mobile optimization is of crucial importance in today’s “mobile-first” world where more than half of searches are done via mobile devices. Therefore, ignoring this aspect of on-page SEO while analyzing your competitors’ sites could lead you to incorrect conclusions.

5. Focusing only on technical aspects: Although technical aspects such as page speed and schema markup are essential for ranking high, they aren’t the be-all and end-all of on-page SEO. Many non-technical factors such as user experience and engaging content play a significant role in driving traffic and retaining visitors.

In conclusion, avoiding these common mistakes will ensure that you get accurate insights when conducting an on-page SEO competitor analysis, leading you towards better online visibility and higher rankings for your website.

For the most advanced AI-powered SEO tool, look no further than to help you amplify your SEO and content game! Sign up today to get started.